Introduction
When your laptop or desktop PC starts having issues, you have two main options – attempt to repair it or replace it entirely. Deciding between repair vs replacement can be tricky. There are pros and cons to both options, so it’s important to consider several factors to determine the best course of action. I’ve created this comprehensive checklist to walk through all the key considerations when deciding whether to repair or replace your computer.
Cost Comparison
The first and most important factor is cost.
-
Repair costs – What specifically is wrong with your device, and how much will it cost to have it fixed? Diagnosis and labor can really add up.
-
Replacement costs – How much is a comparable new laptop or desktop? Would you get better specs and features if you replaced rather than repaired?
-
Resale value – If repaired, how much longer can you continue using your current device, and what is its resale value if you eventually replace it?
To get a true comparison, add up the repair costs versus the price of a new replacement minus potential resale value for your current device.
Lifespan and Use Case
Next, consider how long you want to keep using your current laptop or desktop and what you use it for.
-
Age of device – The older it is, the less worthwhile repairs may be. Newer devices tend to be repairable.
-
Usage habits – Light use vs. heavy use impacts lifespan. Repairs make more sense for lightly used devices.
-
Performance needs – Assessing your performance requirements helps determine if repair extends its usefulness.
-
Upgrades – Upgrading specific components may be an alternative to full replacement.
Repairability Assessment
Not all damage is economically repairable. Assess the specifics of your device’s issues.
-
Warranty coverage – Repairs may be free if still under warranty. Replacement is better if warranty has expired.
-
Parts availability – Some proprietary components can’t be repaired. Limited parts increase costs.
-
Diagnostic fees – These fees get charged even for unrepairable damage. Avoid sinking money into a device that can’t be fixed.
-
Data recovery – Repair shops may charge a lot for data recovery if needed.
-
Repeat failures – If a repaired component fails again quickly, replacement may be better.
New Device Features
If replacing your computer, consider what features you gain with a new one.
-
Faster processor – New CPUs offer big performance gains.
-
More memory – Increased RAM improves multitasking.
-
Larger solid state drive – SSD storage is faster and more reliable.
-
Better display – Higher resolutions and touchscreens improve the experience.
-
Newer ports – USB-C, Thunderbolt 3, and HDMI 2.0 enable connectivity.
-
Improved battery life – Latest batteries last much longer on a charge.
-
Weight savings – New lightweight laptops improve portability.
Summary
-
Carefully compare repair costs to replacement costs and resale value of your old device.
-
Consider how long you plan to use your computer and what you use it for.
-
Realistically assess if your specific damage can be fixed economically and how repairable your model is.
-
Factor in new features and capabilities you’d gain with a replacement device.
Following this repair vs replace checklist will help you make the optimal decision for your situation! Let me know if you have any other questions.
