Securing critical infrastructure against cyber threats is crucial for protecting national security, public health and safety, and economic stability. As the reliance on computer systems and networks grows, so do the risks of cyberattacks that could disrupt critical services and functions. This article examines the key risks and challenges in critical infrastructure security that decision-makers, operators, and security professionals need to understand.
What is Critical Infrastructure?
Critical infrastructure refers to the physical and cyber systems and assets that are so vital to a nation that their incapacity or destruction would have a debilitating impact on national security, economic stability, and public health and safety.
Some examples of critical infrastructure sectors include:
- Energy (electricity, oil, and gas)
- Water and wastewater systems
- Transportation systems (road, rail, aviation, maritime)
- Telecommunications
- Financial services
- Healthcare and public health
- Food and agriculture
These infrastructure sectors provide foundational services and functions that underpin modern societies. Disruptions to critical infrastructure would significantly impair security and economic activity.
Why is Critical Infrastructure Security Important?
Protecting critical infrastructure is vital for several key reasons:
-
National security – Disruption of critical infrastructure like energy or defense industrial bases could undermine a nation’s security, defense capabilities, and public safety.
-
Public health and safety – Disruption of water, healthcare, emergency services, and other critical sectors directly threatens public health and welfare.
-
Economic and societal stability – Most critical infrastructure sectors like finance, energy, and transportation are essential for economic activity and social functioning. Attacks could cause major systemic disruptions.
-
Interconnectedness of systems – Critical infrastructure sectors are increasingly interdependent through digital networks and systems. Disruptions can cascade across sectors.
Given these risks, securing critical infrastructure is a national security priority for governments and the private sector owners and operators of critical systems.
Key Cyber Risks to Critical Infrastructure
Critical infrastructure faces a range of cyber risks that could have severe impacts:
1. Cyberattacks on Industrial Control Systems
Industrial control systems (ICS) like SCADA manage and monitor critical infrastructure. Cyberattacks on ICS could directly disrupt real-world industrial processes, damage equipment, and endanger public safety. The Stuxnet malware that targeted Iranian nuclear facilities demonstrated ICS sabotage risks.
2. Ransomware Attacks
Ransomware denies access to computer systems and data by encryption until a ransom is paid. Ransomware could paralyze critical operations in sectors like healthcare, energy, and transportation. Attacks on facilities like Colonial Pipeline and hospitals highlight the risk.
3. Data Theft and Manipulation
Malicious actors could infiltrate critical infrastructure networks to steal sensitive data or manipulate information to undermine operations. Theft of intellectual property or manipulation of operational data can facilitate sabotage or insider attacks.
4. Disinformation Campaigns
Spreading false information about critical infrastructure incidents could amplify fear and confusion during crises. Foreign influence operations could manipulate public perceptions of infrastructure reliability and security.
5. Insider Threats
Malicious insiders with specialized access could directly sabotage or tamper with systems. Insider risks require robust personnel screening and monitoring.
6. Supply Chain Compromises
Infiltrating the complex global supply chains that provide equipment and software to critical infrastructure could enable cyberattacks further down the line. Vetting suppliers and building in security is key.
Challenges in Critical Infrastructure Cybersecurity
Several factors make securing critical infrastructure uniquely challenging:
-
Legacy technologies – Much critical infrastructure relies on dated, vulnerable technologies not designed with cybersecurity in mind. Upgrading systems is difficult.
-
Interconnectivity – Increased connectivity for efficiency also creates pathways for threats to propagate across networks. Systems once isolated are now exposed.
-
Decentralized ownership – Critical infrastructure spans thousands of public and private entities. Coordinating security improvements across decentralized owners is hard.
-
Specialized threats – Sophisticated adversaries like nation-states develop advanced, stealthy threats tailored to target critical systems and evade detection.
-
Cost barriers – Cybersecurity improvements require major investments that some resource-constrained operators struggle to afford. Finding funds is difficult.
-
Personnel constraints – Many operators lack specialized cybersecurity expertise needed to match sophisticated threats. Developing these skilled professionals nationwide is a challenge.
Key Initiatives for Enhancing Security
Despite the challenges, progress is possible through initiatives such as:
-
Cybersecurity regulations and standards – Governments can impose baseline cybersecurity regulations on critical infrastructure operators. Organizations like NIST also develop consensus standards.
-
Public-private partnerships – Collaborations between government and industry allow intelligence sharing on threats and coordinated security efforts. Programs like the DOE’s Cybersecurity for the Energy Sector (CESER) facilitate this.
-
Vulnerability assessments – Identifying and mitigating weaknesses in critical systems through vulnerability scanning, penetration testing, and other assessment methods improves resilience.
-
Technology upgrades – Transitioning from vulnerable legacy systems and adopting more secure modern IT and industrial control systems bolsters defenses.
-
Personnel training – Educating both cybersecurity and operational staff in critical infrastructure organizations builds essential expertise to counter threats.
-
Incident response planning – Developing and testing cyber incident response plans ensures organizations are prepared to rapidly detect and contain disruptions.
The Path Forward
Critical infrastructure cybersecurity remains a complex risk landscape. But understanding the threats, challenges, and key initiatives allows decision-makers and security professionals to make meaningful progress in safeguarding the essential systems vital to national stability and prosperity against emerging dangers. A vigilant, collaborative approach combining regulation, assessment, technology, and expertise-building offers the most effective way forward.
