Introduction
Industrial control systems (ICS) are vital for operating critical infrastructure sectors such as energy, water, manufacturing, food and agriculture, transportation, and more. However, these systems are increasingly targeted by cyber attacks, putting national security and public safety at risk. In this article, I will discuss the challenges of securing ICS, best practices for mitigating risks, and the role of public-private partnerships in protecting critical infrastructure.
The Threat Landscape for ICS
ICS face a range of cyber threats from hackers, insiders, ransomware, and nation-state actors. Some key threats include:
Targeted Attacks
- Adversaries conduct reconnaissance on ICS networks and use advanced persistent threat (APT) techniques to steal data or cause disruptions. The Triton malware that targeted a Saudi petrochemical plant is an example.
Insider Threats
- Disgruntled employees, contractors, or business partners can sabotage or tamper with control systems due to grievances. Unintentional insider errors also pose risks.
Ransomware
- Destructive ransomware like LockerGoga can affect ICS availability by encrypting files and disrupting operations.
Supply Chain Compromises
- Adversaries target ICS vendors to compromise software/hardware updates and infiltrate customer networks. Examples include software supply chain attacks on SolarWinds and hardware implants on Supermicro servers.
Challenges in Securing ICS Environments
Several unique attributes of ICS environments make them difficult to secure:
Legacy Systems and Proprietary Protocols
- Many ICS use outdated operating systems with vulnerabilities that cannot be patched. They also rely on proprietary protocols rather than standard IT protocols.
Resource Constraints
- ICS have limited computing resources, so security solutions like antivirus cannot be run. Unplanned downtime from security scanning can disrupt physical processes.
Remote Access Requirements
- ICS operators often need remote access for monitoring and control. But remote connections increase exposure to cyber attacks.
Safety Criticality
- Security controls like patching and firewalls can impact ICS availability and safety. Security has to be balanced against operational reliability.
Knowledge Gaps
- IT and OT teams may not collaborate or understand each other’s environments. They need better integration and joint training.
Recommended Security Strategies for ICS
Organizations can take several steps to manage ICS cyber risks:
Network Segmentation
- Physically separate ICS networks from corporate IT networks and use firewalls to restrict connectivity. This limits the blast radius from malware and outsider attacks.
Access Controls
- Permit only necessary users, accounts, and devices. Enforce multi-factor authentication (MFA) for all remote access.
Monitoring for Anomalies
- Collect logs and use behavioral analytics to detect abnormal activities that could signal an attack. Promptly investigate anomalies.
Malware Protection
- Deploy application whitelisting and antivirus tools compatible with ICS. Harden systems by disabling unnecessary services.
Secure Remote Access
- Use VPNs, proxies, and multi-factor authentication for any external connections to ICS. Limit vendor access.
Incident Response Planning
- Have an IR plan specifying roles, processes to isolate ICS, and communication protocols. Conduct regular exercises to test the plan.
Physical Security
- Control and monitor physical access to ICS facilities and devices to prevent direct tampering.
Security Updates
- Regularly update ICS components, applications, and operating systems per vendor guidance. Test patches offline first.
Security Policies
- Define robust cybersecurity policies for the ICS environment covering access, change management, and acceptable use.
User Awareness Training
- Educate ICS operators on risks, security best practices, and responsibilities via regular cybersecurity awareness programs.
Third-Party Risk Management
- Vet critical suppliers like ICS product vendors, MSPs, and integrators. Ensure they meet security standards.
The Role of Public-Private Partnerships
Protecting national critical infrastructure requires collaboration between government and industry:
-
Information sharing allows timely threat intelligence distribution from government to asset owners.
-
Regulations and standards from government bodies like NIST and NERC provide cybersecurity benchmarks for ICS operators.
-
Financial incentives such as grants and tax breaks can help operators offset costs of upgrading legacy ICS.
-
Technology support from government agencies, like threat detection sensors from DHS, helps monitor private sector networks.
-
Trainings and exercises bring together stakeholders from both sectors to enhance incident readiness.
-
R&D initiatives facilitate public and private funding to develop tailored ICS security technologies.
-
International cooperation allows battling global cyber threats affecting critical infrastructure.
Looking Ahead
As ICS underpinning critical infrastructure become more connected, it is crucial to make cybersecurity a priority. A proactive defense-in-depth strategy coupled with public-private cooperation can help secure these vital systems against escalating threats. Organizations should regularly assess risks and controls to achieve resilience against sophisticated and motivated adversaries. With cyber risks poised to intensify, continued progress in ICS cybersecurity is imperative.
